30 Seconds Summary
Is protein really more satiating than carbs and fats?

  • Contrary to popular belief, protein is not consistently more satiating than carbohydrates or fats. This finding is supported by numerous studies that show no significant difference in hunger suppression between high-protein and lower-protein meals.
  • The theory that protein intake suppresses appetite through hormone mediation (like GIP, GLP-1, CCK) is not supported consistently across studies. Higher protein meals do not always result in significantly different levels of satiety hormones compared to lower protein or high carb/fat meals.
  • Protein leverage theory suggests that our bodies regulate appetite based on protein needs. We eat until protein requirements are met, making protein more satiating up to a certain point, after which the additional satiating effect diminishes.
  • Research indicates that while protein can be more satiating in the short term, its effect does not necessarily lead to better long-term weight management. Overconsumption of protein might even lead to an increased risk of overweight and obesity.
  • The optimal protein intake for satiety aligns closely with bodily requirements for protein, generally about 1.2 g/kg/day for non-strength training individuals. Increasing protein intake beyond this does not consistently improve satiety or reduce calorie intake.
  • Pure macronutrient comparisons are less practical than considering overall dietary patterns. Factors like food volume, fiber content, and meal composition have significant impacts on satiety, often overshadowing the effects of protein alone.
  • Vegetables and other low-calorie, high-volume foods are typically more satiating than high-protein foods, challenging the notion that protein-rich diets are inherently more appetite-suppressing.
  • Final verdict: Protein is not inherently more satiating than carbs or fats. Effective appetite control involves more than just manipulating protein intake; it includes considering a variety of foods and their properties.
WorkoutWiseWorkoutWiseWorkoutWise

Track & Plan Workouts
with Ease

  • Unlimited workout logs
  • Automatic volume tracking
  • Personalized programs
  • RPE support, rest timer, and more!
Download for Free
WorkoutWise Screenshot

Read Next

Is Gluten Really That Bad for You?

Before you decide to cut gluten out of your diet in the name of “health,” read up on the science behind the deeply misunderstood protein.

Biolayne

Andres Vargas

Read Summary in 30 Seconds

Do you need a slow-digesting protein to maximize overnight muscle protein synthesis?

Do slow-digesting proteins really outperform faster-digesting proteins? And do we really need to worry about pre-sleep protein ingestion?

Stronger By Science

Greg Nuckols

Read Summary in 30 Seconds

The myth of 1 g/lb: Optimal protein intake for bodybuilders

Protein. It’s every bodybuilder’s favorite macronutrient and for good reason. Protein is extremely essential, super satiating and amazingly anabolic. Protein is awesome… but you’re consuming too much of it. Like most myths, the belief that you should take in 1g/lb of body weight has become so deeply…

MennoHenselmans.com

Menno Henselmans

Read Summary in 30 Seconds

Protein: The Vessel for Growth

Macronutrients It is likely that if you are reading this, you in part have a fairly good understanding of macronutrients or at the very least, have heard the word before. Simply put, these macros are a way to categorize substrates that we take in large quantities. We conventionally view carbohydrate…

Revive Stronger

Danny Wirt

Read Summary in 30 Seconds

Protein: More Than Just Muscle Building Substrate

Protein, the jack of all trades, does more than just build muscle. Find out how a high protein diet helps you burn that unwanted body fat.

Biolayne

Layne Norton

Read Summary in 30 Seconds