30 Seconds Summary
Most lifters probably train too light

  • Most lifters self-select weights that are too light, averaging around 53.14% of their 1-repetition maximum (1RM), which may not be optimal for muscle growth.
  • An analysis finds that individuates usually complete more reps than they intend (e.g., performing 16 reps when they chose a weight for 10), suggesting a significant underestimation in load selection.
  • Research shows little difference in weights chosen based on background factors like training status, age, or sex, and even after performing a 1RM test to gauge strength.
  • Despite different study instructions and exercise prescriptions, people tend to favor weights that let them do around 10 reps, which is relatively consistent across studies.
  • Longitudinal studies suggest an initial conservative load selection with a gradual increase over time, though people continue to select weights with many reps left in reserve.
  • The findings indicate that for effective muscle growth, lifters need to choose heavier weights, closer to failure, as consistent underestimation leads to underwhelming strength gains and muscle development.

Track & Plan Workouts
with Ease

  • Unlimited workout logs
  • Automatic volume tracking
  • Personalized programs
  • RPE support, rest timer, and more!
WorkoutWise Screenshot

Read Next

Everything You Think is Wrong With Your Deadlift Technique Is Probably Right

Round your back when you deadlift? Here’s why doing so makes the lift more mechanically efficient. Bonus: How to know the best deadlift setup for YOU.

Stronger By Science

Greg Nuckols

Fixing the Good-Morning Squat

Your butt’s shooting up for a reason you probably aren’t expecting. Learn to fix a good-morning squat and build a stronger squat.

Stronger By Science

Greg Nuckols

How strong can you get without steroids? Strength standards for natural lifters

What are realistic strength goals for natural lifters? One way to answer this question is to look at natural powerlifting records, but just because somebody competed in a natural, drug-tested federation, does not mean they never used performance enhancing drugs. It just means that they didn’t fail t…

MennoHenselmans.com

Menno Henselmans

Strong Starts in the Mind: The Benefits of Active Imagery for Lifters

Active imagery (or visualization) DOES have a role in building strong lifts. Here’s what it is and how to implement it.

Stronger By Science

Luke Mitchell

Research Spotlight: Trained lifters are primarily stronger due to muscularity, not neural adaptations

The study reviewed is “Behavior of Motor Units during Submaximal Isometric Contractions in Chronically Strength-Trained Individuals” by Casolo et al.

Stronger By Science

Greg Nuckols