30 Seconds Summary
Diet Tracking and Disordered Eating: Which Comes First?

  • The study investigated the effects of diet tracking via MyFitnessPal on mental health and eating behaviors among 200 female college students without eating disorders, finding no significant negative impacts.
  • This randomized controlled trial did not show improvements in physical activity and other health behaviors despite tracking dietary intake.
  • Definitions of disordered eating vary; the article adopts a definition focused on pathological dietary behaviors driven by negative psychological symptoms related to body image.
  • Cross-sectional studies suggest an association between diet tracking and higher prevalence of eating disorders, though causation is not established.
  • The study emphasizes that diet tracking did not increase eating disorder symptoms or deleterious mental health effects in a controlled setting.
  • It raises questions about the effectiveness of diet apps in improving health behaviors and the potential risks for individuals with a predisposition to eating disorders.
  • Authors suggest a cautious approach when recommending diet tracking, especially for individuals with past disordered eating behaviors or other vulnerabilities.
  • The study underscores the importance of flexible diet approaches rather than rigid dietary restraint to avoid psychological distress or disordered eating.

Track & Plan Workouts
with Ease

  • Unlimited workout logs
  • Automatic volume tracking
  • Personalized programs
  • RPE support, rest timer, and more!
WorkoutWise Screenshot

Read Next

Self-Licensing: How Good Behavior Leads To Bad Behavior

The following is a guest article by John Fawkes. Am evidence-based trainer and long-time student of Menno’s, John has previously written an article for this site about diet and exercise program compliance, and currently has recently moved his writing on fitness and scientific research to a new Subs…

MennoHenselmans.com

John Fawkes

An Unbiased Look At Artificial Sweeteners

Artificial Sweeteners - how much bitter truth is there behind the sensationalistic headlines? Who should use them, and who’s better off avoiding them?

Stronger By Science

Tanner Baze

Should you program diet breaks while cutting?

Diet breaks are a popular dieting tool in evidence-based fitness circles. Diet breaks are claimed to improve muscle retention, fat loss and diet adherence. We collaborated with the University of South Florida and other researchers to investigate if there was any truth to these claims in our newly pu…

MennoHenselmans.com

Menno Henselmans

Diet Breaks: How and Why to Use Them

Diet breaks are renowned for psychological benefits, but research indicates they also play a physiological role in successful fat loss diets.

Biolayne

Eric Trexler

New study: Do diet breaks help preserve muscle mass and your metabolism?

Do diet breaks help preserve muscle mass or your metabolism? If you’ve been following my work for a while, you should know my answer, but a great new study by my highly respected colleagues Jackson Peos, Eric Helms, James Krieger et al. provides more hard data in strength trainees. The trainees perf…

MennoHenselmans.com

Menno Henselmans